Ownership and Transferability in Tokenized Assets

Understanding Ownership and Transferability in Tokenization

Ownership and transferability of tokenized assets are governed by national property laws, securities regulations, and investment restrictions. While tokenization enables fractional ownership and global investor access, some jurisdictions impose legal restrictions on asset ownership, foreign investment, and securities transfers.

Before issuing tokenized assets, it is critical to assess:

1. Who is legally allowed to own the underlying asset? – Some countries restrict foreign ownership of real estate, corporate shares, or strategic assets.

2. Can fractional ownership through tokenization be legally recognized? – Some jurisdictions require whole asset ownership, preventing legally enforceable fractional ownership.

3. Are there restrictions on transferring ownership via blockchain tokens? – Securities and property laws may require formal registration for ownership transfers, making decentralized transactions invalid.

Failure to ensure compliance with ownership and transferability regulations can lead to legal disputes, invalid asset claims, and financial losses for investors.

Key Considerations in Ownership and Transferability

Are There Restrictions on Foreign Investors Owning Tokenized Assets?

Many jurisdictions regulate foreign ownership of certain asset classes due to economic, security, or political concerns.

Common Foreign Ownership Restrictions:

• Real Estate: Countries such as Switzerland, Thailand, Indonesia, and Australia impose limits on foreign individuals or entities acquiring land or property.

• Corporate Shares: Some countries prohibit foreign ownership of companies in specific industries (e.g., energy, defense, banking).

• Securities: Some jurisdictions restrict non-resident investors from holding domestic securities, requiring local brokerage accounts or specific approvals.

If a tokenized asset cannot legally be held by foreign investors, token holders may not have enforceable ownership rights, making the investment effectively worthless.

Legal Tests for Foreign Ownership Compliance

To determine whether foreign investors can own a tokenized asset, issuers must assess:

• Is the asset legally transferrable to foreign entities?

• Are there nationality restrictions on ownership?

• Can a foreign-based SPV legally hold the asset?

• Do tax or regulatory requirements limit foreign participation?

For example, a tokenized real estate asset in Thailand cannot be directly owned by a foreign investor unless structured through a legal entity (e.g., an SPV or trust) that complies with Thai foreign investment laws.

Can Fractional Ownership Through Tokens Be Legally Recognized?

Tokenization allows multiple investors to own fractional shares of an asset, but legal recognition depends on:

• Jurisdictional property laws – Some legal systems only recognize whole ownership structures, making fractional real estate tokens legally unenforceable.

• Securities classification – If tokenized ownership is structured as investment contracts or shares, it may require securities registration.

• Corporate structures for ownership – Using an SPV or REIT-like structure may provide a legal framework for fractionalized ownership.

Example: How Fractional Ownership is Treated in Different Jurisdictions

Jurisdiction	Is Fractional Real Estate Ownership Allowed?	Regulatory Considerations
United States	Yes	Must comply with SEC regulations if structured as securities.
Switzerland	No (Direct property ownership)	Requires corporate ownership structure.
United Arab Emirates	Yes (Limited)	Subject to foreign ownership zones.
Thailand	No (Land restrictions)	Foreigners cannot own land directly.
Singapore	Yes	Subject to real estate investment laws.

If fractional ownership is not legally enforceable, investors may not have real legal claims to the asset, even if they hold the token.

Are There Restrictions on Transferring Ownership via Blockchain Tokens?

While blockchain technology enables instant, global asset transfers, traditional property and securities laws still require formal legal processes for ownership transfers.

Key Legal Considerations in Token Transfers:

• Real Estate – Many jurisdictions require title deed registration through a government authority, meaning blockchain-based transfers alone do not constitute legal ownership changes.

• Securities – In most countries, securities transfers must be registered through regulated exchanges or custodians for legal recognition.

• Financial Reporting – Some countries impose capital controls or reporting requirements on cross-border ownership transfers, even for tokenized assets.

Example: Legal Barriers to Token Transfers

Tokenized Asset Type	Can Ownership Be Transferred via Blockchain?	Legal Requirements
Real Estate (Direct Ownership)	No (Conditional)	Requires title registration with a land registry.
Company Shares	No (Conditional)	Requires update to corporate shareholder records.
Tokenized Bonds	Yes	If issued through a regulated securities exchange.
REIT Tokens	Yes	If structured as tradable securities.

If blockchain transactions do not satisfy legal transfer requirements, the token holder may not have recognized ownership rights, exposing them to financial and legal risks.

---

Why Ownership and Transferability Are Critical in Tokenization

1. Ensures Legal Enforceability – Investors must have clear, legal claims to their tokenized assets.

2. Prevents Invalid Transactions – Blockchain-based transfers must be legally recognized by national property and securities laws.

3. Avoids Foreign Ownership Restrictions – Issuers must ensure that international investors can legally hold and trade the asset.

4. Supports Secondary Market Trading – If tokenized assets cannot be legally transferred, liquidity and market adoption are limited.

Failing to comply with ownership and transferability laws can lead to asset seizure, invalid transactions, and legal action against issuers and investors.

---

Steps to Ensure Ownership and Transferability Compliance

1. Verify foreign ownership restrictions before offering tokenized assets to international investors.

2. Confirm legal recognition of fractional ownership to ensure token holders have enforceable asset claims.

3. Assess whether blockchain transfers satisfy legal requirements for ownership changes.

4. Work with legal advisors to structure tokenized assets using compliant corporate or trust frameworks.

5. Choose jurisdictions that support digital ownership for tokenized assets and secondary trading.

By addressing ownership and transferability regulations upfront, token issuers can create legally compliant, secure, and globally tradable digital assets.

---